E+Co Enterprise Development Services (EDS)
The E+Co Enterprise Development Services (EDS) Program provides training and skills development to early stage clean energy entrepreneurs. These services fill a market gap, enabling entrepreneurs to gain the skills and knowledge to create “bankable” business plans that can qualify him/her for financing to launch/grow a clean energy enterprise.
About You
About You
First Name
Anne
Last Name
Murray
Website
Your Organization
E+Co
Country
United States
About Your Organization
Organization Name
E+Co
Organization Website
Organization Phone
+1 973 680 9100
Organization Address
383 Franklin St. Bloomfield
Organization Country
United States, NJ, Essex County
Organization Type
Non-profit/NGO/Citizen-sector Organization
The information you provide here will be used to fill in any parts of your profile that have been left blank, such as interests, organization information, and website. No contact information will be made public. Please uncheck here if you do not want this to happen..
Your solution
Name Your solution
E+Co Enterprise Development Services (EDS)
Describe Your Solution
The E+Co Enterprise Development Services (EDS) Program provides training and skills development to early stage clean energy entrepreneurs. These services fill a market gap, enabling entrepreneurs to gain the skills and knowledge to create “bankable” business plans that can qualify him/her for financing to launch/grow a clean energy enterprise.
Country your work focuses on
If multiple countries, please list them here. If your solution targets an entire region, please select it below
Region(s) your solution focuses on:
Africa, Latin America and the Caribbean, South Asia.
Range of turnover in your target firms, in USD
Less than $1 Million.
Average turnover in USD of your target firm
$1 million
Number of employees in your target firms
5-24.
Average number of employees of your target firm
20
Specify the size, average and range of expected loans or investments in each target firm
E+Co investment for early stage entrepreneurs generally ranges from $25,000-$300,000, averaging $100,000-$200,000. The degree of EDS provided is based on the needs of the entrepreneur, although at this early stage it is very labor intensive and time consuming.
What stage is your solution in?
Operating for more than 5 years
Innovation
What makes your innovative solution unique?
The E+Co Enterprise Development Services (EDS) program is unique in that no other financial institution begins work with an entrepreneur long before a business plan is “bankable” and ready to be financed. Entrepreneurs are generally “on their own” in terms of gaining skills and knowledge to develop their plans. In the developing world, E+Co is unique in a) providing these skills and b) providing them at no cost to the entrepreneur. EDS is localized and customized to address the needs of the entrepreneur, conducted one-on-one, via the phone, or via the internet by E+Co staff in local E+Co offices.
The EDS program includes basic areas of learning – bookkeeping/accounting, market assessments and segmentation, carbon finance basics, clean energy technologies, staff training/hiring, systems, and risk evaluations. Through the EDS process, E+Co is able to gauge both the knowledge capacity and the commitment of the entrepreneur to persevere and succeed, assessing whether the entrepreneur will be a safe investment risk. Through working with these entrepreneurs, in some cases for months and even years, and sharing E+Co’s knowledge and expertise, E+Co reduces its own investment risk.
Says Kofi Asante of E+Co portfolio company Abara Gas in Ghana about his experiences: ”I worked on my own to develop a business plan, but the questions that I got from E+Co Africa Regional Manager Kofi Nketsia-Tabiri helped me look at my plan in a different way. I realized that I was getting ahead of myself…his input helped me trim the project into a more manageable size.”
How does your proposed innovation leverage public intervention in catalyzing private SME finance?
Fifteen years ago, E+Co determined that the best way to address climate change and poverty issues in developing countries was through the development and financing of small and growing clean energy enterprises – businesses that would be local, that would serve the needs of local customers, that would create jobs, and that would provide lasting economic growth in regions and countries. But it also recognized that a gap existed in these markets – there were no institutions that would enable aspiring entrepreneurs to gain the basic business and clean energy knowledge, skills and training they needed to develop a ‘bankable’ business plan and gain financing to start their business. And there were no financial institutions willing to provide capital to small, risky, under-collateralized enterprises. And so E+Co launched to provide both Enterprise Development Services and Capital, a “market-based, entrepreneur-centric” model of clean energy enterprise.
It has been our experience, however, that it all really begins with Enterprise Development Services, and that is the solution we are promoting here. Because without the basic skills training, the strategy development, the advice, handholding and encouragement that E+Co regional staff provide, enterprises would remain an idea, an aspiration, but not a reality. E+Co helps the entrepreneur build out and build up his dream, putting ideas to paper, resulting in a business plan with the basic foundation intact upon which it can grow, with the financing that E+Co provides, and that other private finance institutions will come to provide.
E+Co’s experience with its own portfolio companies, such as Tecnosol, Nicaragua confirms this. E+Co first began working with Tecnosol in 2000, with funding from USAID’s FENERCA program. The program supported capacity building of clean energy entrepreneurs in Central and South America and Africa. After significant EDS work provided by E+Co, Tecnosol was able to secure capital from E+Co in 2003. E+Co continued to provide investment capital, and in 2010, Tecnosol was able to secure local equity investment in 2010 to support their expansion into El Salvador and Panama. There is little question that the entrepreneur behind Tecnosol, Vladimir Delagneau, possesses the determination and the persistence required to succeed as an entrepreneur, especially in developing economies. However, E+Co’s training, support and guidance also impacted his success. Upon receiving the Ashden Award for Sustainable Energy in 2010, Delagneau commented: “I want to thank E+Co, because without its support, this accomplishment would not have been possible.”
What barriers does your proposed solution address?
Lack of SME access to skills / knowledge / markets.
If you checked any of these barriers, describe how your solution addresses them
E+Co’s solution addresses “Lack of SME access to skills/knowledge/markets”. However, because without this training an entrepreneur cannot develop a ‘bankable’ business plan to qualify for financing, this lack of access to skills/knowledge/markets also impacts his/her access to capital. While we are seeing that local capital, primarily from development banks and intermediaries like E+Co, is becoming more available in developing world markets, the disbursement of that capital continues to be constrained by lack of entrepreneur skills and training.
Most investors expect that an enterprise is “investment ready.” They are willing to support the enterprise ‘post investment’ but are not prepared to do the heavy lifting to prepare him/her beforehand. Local institutions also lack the capacity to provide this training and development.
E+Co’s model links services and capital as the joint critical components to successful entrepreneur development. Training is currently provided using toolkits and other E+Co publications in one-to-one meetings and consultations between the entrepreneur and E+Co regional staff. While this training is critical, what becomes equally important in this process is the advice and connections that E+Co staff, so rooted in these markets, are able to provide.
In Ghana, entrepreneur Malam Abukari Amadu, promoter of Lambark Gas, a distributor of Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG), indicated that “after receiving my oil marketing company (OMC) license, I spent four months looking for a bank guarantee. When I informed E+Co Investment Officer Vincent Yankey, he reached out to a local bank and helped me secure a guarantee that same day.” In another case, Reality Energy in Ghana received a recommendation from Vincent Yankey to use an accounting system “…that would allow us to have a database of our clients and to track our expenses.” Now Reality Energy is using that system to improve customer relations and design customized market strategies.
E+Co understands that it can be lonely and discouraging to work through the process of launching and growing a business, especially in regions where there are significant barriers to success. The personal connection provided by E+Co staff, which is as important a part of Enterprise Development Services as the training and skills development, is equally as important for these entrepreneurs to keep them motivated and focused. No other institution in these markets is providing this level of service.
Says Clara Mankata, owner and operator of M38 Ventures, an LPG enterprise in Ghana, of E+Co support: “When a traditional institution gives you a loan, it only cares about you paying it back. It would not concern itself with your business problems. That is how E+Co is different.”
Impact
Provide empirical evidence of your proposed solution's success/impact at present. If your project is in the idea phase, please provide evidence that speaks to its potential impact
Since 1994, E+Co has supported +1,200 entrepreneurs, and has made a combination of 268 seed and growth investments totaling $40 million. The portfolio investment return (after write- offs and before costs) during this period is 8.7%. Considering the risky nature of investment in these markets, this is an admirable return, which we attribute in large part to the impact of EDS.
These entrepreneurs have significant impact in these markets, in many cases providing clean energy for the first time to local communities, taking their customers from dirty fuels like kerosene and firewood, to clean and cleaner energy sources like solar, energy efficient cook stoves, liquefied petroleum gas, waste to energy (for industrial operations), wind and hydropower. These entrepreneurs are stepping in where local governments have either failed, or haven’t made the effort, to change the living conditions of local communities.
They are providing products and services that are available, affordable and appropriate to their customers. This is not a donor driven model, where the energy poor are provided products and services they may not want or need. Rather, the enterprise-customer relationship is established and developed as a lasting, local communion in commerce, benefitting both sides of a business transaction. The impact of these entrepreneurs is increasingly recognized globally, by organizations such as the Ashden Awards for Sustainable Energy, Schwab Foundation for Social Entrepreneurship, Lighting Rural Tanzania, and Clinton Global Initiative. Each of these organizations have selected E+Co portfolio company entrepreneurs as worthy of their awards, a great recognition of the successes these enterprises have achieved.
In Karatu, Tanzania, the Mwema Orphanage, far from the grid, was previously unelectrified. The orphans were often at risk from the hazards of dirty fuels – kerosene that spilled and caused fires, smoke that resulted in frequent trips to the doctor. But with the support of local solar enterprise Ensol, a Tanzanian enterprise that received EDS and capital from E+Co, the orphanage now gets its power from solar PV panels on the roof. According the Pastor Elisante Mwengoha, Manager of the orphanage: “…here, there are so few choices, you can either have firewood, kerosene or the grid. I did not know that places like ours could afford solar power.” According to Ensol’s Director, Prosper Magali, “the local (Ensol) branch in Karatu is performing well. I can say it is beyond our expectations.” Both enterprise and customer win.
How many firms do you expect to reach?
Under the current EDS model, E+Co will continue to reach approximately 100-125 entrepreneurs annually, making approximately 25-30 investments annually. With funding to expand staffing to provide EDS to more entrepreneurs, E+Co projects that it would reach an additional 25-30 entrepreneurs annually (total 125-150 annually), and make approximately 35-50 investments annually.
What is the volume of private SME finance you aim to catalyze?
From 1998-2009, E+Co mobilized $253 million in capital for clean energy SMEs. At this rate, we project that E+Co will mobilize over $440 million in capital by the end of 2013. With additional staffing to increase EDS, leading to expanded investment, we project to mobilize $525 million.
What time frame will be required to reach these targets?
Projection to achieve targets as above by the end of 2013.
Does your solution seek to have an impact on public policy?
No
What would prevent your solution from being a success?
The E+Co model of services and capital has a fifteen year track record of success and impact, and we expect that to continue. The dilemmas of addressing the needs of energy poverty and climate change continue to confound. E+Co’s model continues as one of the few models that have had success.
Changes in developing world market conditions (war, corruption, economic declines, etc.) may impact the interest of entrepreneurs to launch clean energy enterprises, thereby reducing interest in E+Co EDS and capital. If local institutions were to begin providing a version of EDS and capital to clean energy SMEs, or should affordable access to grid electricity expand significantly, that would reduce the need for E+Co’s involvement in these markets. After fifteen years, however, we have yet to see that happen.
To effectively provide early stage entrepreneurs with EDS and equip them with the necessary tools and training, however, E+Co itself will be constrained from further growth without additional staff resources to carry out this work. At the present time, we are seeking to add three regional staff (two in Africa, one in Central America) to provide expanded EDS.
This Entry is about (Issues)
Describe the social impact of your innovation. Please include both numbers and stories as evidence of this impact
E+Co provides EDS and capital for the purpose of reducing the impact of energy poverty and climate change, as the enterprises that E+Co supports have the same mission.
E+Co measures both social and environmental impact from investment, which is tallied annually via 30 metrics. E+Co Monitoring & Evaluation Officers travel to the communities served by the entrepreneurs and collect data first hand, as well as via reports provided by entrepreneurs. Some highlights from the most recent “Triple Bottom Line” report (January 1998 - December 2009) include:
- 6.2 million people with access to clean energy
- +5,300 jobs supported
- 24 million tons of carbon offset over the life of projects
- 60 million liters of kerosene displaced
- 693,000 tons of charcoal displaced
- 460,000 tons of firewood displaced
- 910,000 barrels of oil displaced
Communities are served in various ways as a result of the work of entrepreneurs. Entrepreneur Suraj Wahab O of Toyola Energy Ltd. in Ghana enables local communities to replace firewood and animal fuel for cooking with energy efficient charcoal stoves that are 40% more efficient. He has his own system of ‘evangelists’ who receive $1 for each $8 cook stove sold. He has also begun distribution of solar lanterns to reduce reliance on kerosene. Because he doesn’t have the support of local financial institutions to implement ‘end user credit’ to facilitate consumer purchase of products, he has his own method of collection. He has customers put the money they save since they no longer need to buy kerosene into a “kerosene can”, and each week he and his local team collect those savings until the lantern is paid off.
Innovation in these markets takes many forms, E+Co EDS unleashes it.
Sustainability
List all the funding sources that are required for the sustainability of this solution
Currently, E+Co’s funding to support its EDS program comes from grant funding provided by foundations, development banks and private donations. It is estimated that EDS expense is US $.30 of every US $1 invested. The economic recession which began in 2008 has reduced available funding to the organization, albeit with no cutback in our EDS service to date, but we will require new funding sources to ramp up the provision of EDS.
In order to increase the number of entrepreneurs served via EDS, E+Co projects that three additional staff would facilitate significant increases in the number of entrepreneurs trained, and the number of entrepreneurs to receive investment. The Africa and Central America regions are most in need of this support.
We are seeking grant funding to hire these three staff for a two year period, projected funding required is $510,000 ($85,000 per staff per year).
Without this funding, we will continue to provide EDS, but will not be able to significantly increase the training, support and subsequent investment that the markets require.
Demonstrate how your proposed solution has the capacity to graduate from dependence on public finance. What is the time frame?
There will always be some need for grant support to provide EDS to these early stage entrepreneurs – few, if any, local institutions are presently willing to pay for this. Yet it remains critical to the markets because of the impact on local economies. Increasingly there is recognition of the power of the entrepreneur, especially in emerging markets, “which are building and redefining industries that satisfy domestic demand and generate export income—not to mention create employment for the rapidly growing younger population.” (Harvard Business Review, September 2010).
In the US, these services are generally available at no cost to entrepreneurs via academic institutions, SBA-associated organizations and others, all of which generally have some government-funded support. In the developing world, local government organizations are not providing this funding, it takes intermediaries like E+Co, with non-local private funding to support this work.
This type of support should receive public support, as it does in the US, where it has been effectively catalyzing private investment for some time. At some point, developing world governments may fund these services, but that is not yet the case, and so private funding for intermediaries like E+Co remains critical. The impact of these services, however, is already catalyzing private investment, and that will only increase as more enterprises launch, grow and succeed.
Demonstrate how your proposed solution will survive a potential loss of its largest private funding source
Any loss in funding will reduce the amount of EDS provided and will lengthen the process for entrepreneurs to develop their business plans. However, EDS is critical to E+Co’s mission, and it will continue to allocate resources, even if more limited than at present, to carry out these programs. The “Great Recession” has caused shortfalls in sourced funding, although to date it has not negatively impacted our ability to provide EDS, but without new funding beginning in 2011, we will start to feel the impact.
E+Co has always provided these services at no cost to entrepreneurs, as few could afford to pay for them in these developing world economies. We are evaluating a “fee” based system, which we are loath to implement but may become necessary.
We are working to reduce the costs of providing EDS, currently estimated to cost US $.30 per US $1 invested. In order to take advantage of internet and telephony technologies, we are developing an online, interactive, mentor-supported training platform called the “Invisible Schoolhouse” (see separate submission to the G20 SME Finance Challenge as a “solution”). The launch of this platform is intended to accelerate the learning process and enable entrepreneurs to spend some time in independent learning, although E+Co regional staff will continue to spend face-to-face time with entrepreneurs in traditional EDS.
We continue to evaluate other sources of funding to facilitate and grow the EDS platform, including government contracts similar to the USAID FENERCA program, implemented by E+Co in 2000.
Please tell us what kind of partnerships, if any, could be critical to the greater success and sustainability of your innovation
Partnerships with like-minded organizations are always being evaluated – the World Bank Energy group and the InfoDev group and USAID are just a few examples. Clean Energy affiliated organizations, including DOE Global Village Energy Program (GVEP) are others. We believe that by working in partnership we have the ability to have greater impact.
E+Co is a founding member of ANDE (Aspen Network of Development Entrepreneurs), which has a commitment to growing the small and growing clean energy sector, and we support and work jointly with the organization and its 80+ members in the development of opportunity in developing world markets.
Are there non-financial issues that could threaten the sustainability of your proposed solution?
Because EDS is carried out by regional E+Co offices staffed locally, we have never faced any backlash from local institutions in doing this work, but should local governments and/or other institutions place restrictions on our abilities, as a US based non-profit, to carry out this work, our solution could be impacted.
Should local institutions in the developing world begin to provide the same level of Enterprise Development Services that E+Co provides, we believe this would only increase the demand for these services overall, and therefore drive more entrepreneurs to providers like E+Co.
Please tell us if your proposed solution aims to scale up through a high growth sector, expand immediately to multiple sectors, and/or scale up geographically
The demand for clean energy as a solution to energy poverty and climate change has been increasing, and the success of the ‘clean energy enterprise’ solution is recognized by increasing numbers of institutions. E+Co has traditionally focused on the provision of services and capital to smaller scale enterprises that serve rural and peri-urban regions, as that is where there have been significant gaps, and where E+Co’s role in these markets has have the greatest impact. We will maintain a focus on providing EDS to early stage entrepreneurs, but we are seeing increasing opportunities at scale. E+Co’s deep seated knowledge of clean energy enterprise will facilitate the growth in impact the organization can have both in the EDS it provides to entrepreneurs at varying levels of growth, as well as investment.
E+Co’s success has resulted from a singular focus on clean energy, but we do see opportunities to provide EDS to other sectors, especially those with a connection to clean energy, such as agriculture, health, sanitation, water, etc. We have already entertained opportunities to provide EDS to facilitate, for example, distribution of solar refrigerators for clinics, as just one example. Of our own choosing, we have been conservative in our growth to date, but the markets increasingly are demanding we scale to new levels of impact. We will, however, not deviate from our core work in clean energy.
Geographically, E+Co has been selective in determining the countries in which it operates, which limits the provision of EDS. Because EDS has traditionally required much personal interaction, that places great importance on the knowledge of local markets, we have limited the provision of EDS and Capital to approximately 21 markets to date. We will continue to evaluate expansion into new countries and regions opportunistically, although we continue to explore partnerships which would enable us to work with organizations already familiar with a region or market. As clean energy becomes a greater consideration for development, we expect that we will increase the geographic regions where we will expand our influence.
| 141 weeks ago Anne Murray updated this Competition Entry. | |
| 141 weeks ago Anne Murray updated this Competition Entry. | |
| 141 weeks ago Anne Murray updated this Competition Entry. | |
| 141 weeks ago Anne Murray submitted this idea. |

