Disruptive Innovations in Health and Health Care: Solutions People Want

Disruptive Innovations in Health and Health Care

Solutions People Want

Competition Information

Competition News

Pioneer Portfolio of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation has completed reviewing the entire set of entries received in the Disruptive Innovations in Health and Health Care competition. RWJF has announced that 11 entrants have been invited to compete for the $5 million in grant funding.

Welcome Letter from Robert Wood Johnson Foundation



Dear Changemakers Community,

Welcome to “Disruptive Innovations in Health and Health Care: Solutions People Want.” This is the second in a series of Changemakers’s collaborative competitions sponsored by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF) through its Pioneer Portfolio.

RWJF’s mission is to improve the health and health care of all Americans. Our grant making covers a range of pressing issues including: reversing the rise in childhood obesity rates; improving the quality of care; raising the visibility, effectiveness and readiness of the public health system; and ensuring affordable health care coverage for all Americans. RWJF’s Pioneer Portfolio is a distinct pool of funding to support novel, high-return ideas that may have far-reaching impact on people’s health, the quality of care they receive and the systems through which that care is provided. You can learn more about our work at rwjf.org/pioneer.

We are pleased to be able to partner with Changemakers on this competition on disruptive innovation because it gets at the heart of what drives Pioneer– finding innovations that can transform health and health care. Harvard Business School Professor Clayton Christensen coined the term “disruptive innovation” to describe a technology, process, or business model that brings to market a product or service that is much more affordable and much simpler to use than what is currently available. In so doing, more consumers in the market can afford and/or have the ability to use the product or service. The change caused by such an innovation is so big that it eventually replaces, or disrupts, the established approach to providing that product or service.

In some instances, the effects of such innovations are big and bold enough to transform business, markets, populations…even entire societies. It is our hope that the projects entered in the Disruptive Innovations competition can trigger similarly positive and profound change in health and health care in the United States. We look forward to seeing your innovative solutions for how we can improve access to care, lower costs, promote greater efficiency, and deliver higher-quality services in ways that empower consumers.

Following the Changemakers competition, selected entries will be invited to submit proposals to RWJF’s Pioneer Portfolio for future funding consideration. A total of up to $5 million in grants is available to support promising disruptive innovations in health and health care. The Foundation will be looking particularly for innovations that show potential to produce significant improvement in health and health care in the U.S. Organizations must operate in the U.S. or its territories in order to be eligible for RWJF funding.

We invite you to participate by entering your disruptive innovation on the Changemakers Mosaic of Solutions, which serves as the framework for identifying the principles for and barriers to enabling disruptive innovation. The competition is intended to offer you the opportunity to showcase your ideas and your work, and it provides RWJF a uniquely valuable and rich opportunity to learn about what solutions hold promise.

As a part of the Changemakers global community, we want you to help test and refine the ideas surfacing through this competition – we call your attention to the online review option that accompanies each entry, and invite you to share your thoughts and reactions throughout the stages of the competition. This level of collaboration is what will help to surface new innovations and connect participants to new ideas, partners, and resources. We also invite you to join the on-line discussion about what constitutes disruptive innovation and at what stage in the idea process it can be identified and nurtured. We look forward to participating with you in an active, dynamic exchange of ideas.


Nancy Barrand

Senior Program Officer

Robert Wood Johnson Foundation

P.S. Click here for more on disruptive innovation

Guidelines and Assessment



Welcome to the Changemakers “Disruptive Innovations in Health and Health Care: Solutions People Want” Collaborative Competition, which aims to find innovative solutions and catalyze a community of changemakers around the disruptive innovations transforming health and health care.






Eligibility Criteria

The competition will be open to all types of organizations (charitable organizations, private companies, or public entities) from all countries. We consider all entries that:

    • Reflect the theme of the competition: Disruptive Innovations. The scope of the competition is to identify “disruptive innovations” able to transform health and health care. Entries are invited from organizations in all countries and proposed solutions should inform work being done in the U.S and around the world.
    • Are beyond the stage of idea, concept, or research, and, at a minimum, are at the demonstration stage and indicate success.
    • Are submitted in English and are complete.




Assessment Criteria

The winners of this Changemakers Collaborative Competition will be those entries that best meet the following criteria:

    Disruptive Innovation: This is the knock-out test. The application must describe the disruptive innovation that it is focused on. Does the innovation clearly reflect the ability to systemically transform health and health care by focusing on greater simplicity, lower cost, and enhanced convenience of services to more powerful, informed consumers? Does it enable more consumers in that market to afford and/or have the skill to use the product or service? Is the change caused by such an innovation so big, that it eventually replaces, or disrupts, the established approach to providing that product or service?
    Social Impact: It is important that the innovation has begun to have an impact on the field it addresses. Some innovations will have proven success at a small level, while others will have scaled to engage millions of people. Regardless of the level of demonstrated impact, it is important to see that the innovation has the ability to affect the world and not just one village. This will be judged by considering the scale strategy, ability to be replicated, clear how-tos, and a map to reach the big goals.
    Sustainability: For an innovation to be truly effective it must have a plan for how it will acquire financial and other bases of support for the long-term. Are strong partnerships in place for it to have a ripple effect? Is there a clear financial plan in place?




Competition Deadlines, Procedures, and Rules


Deadlines and procedure for entries will be announced shortly.


There are three main phases in the competition:

    Entry Stage - May 2 to July 18, 2007:Entries can be submitted until 12 pm Eastern US time on July18, 2007, and anyone can participate in an online idea review discussion with the entrants.
    Close of Entry Stage and Judging - July 18 to August 15, 2007: Online idea review discussion continues. In parallel, a panel of judges well-versed in the topic and Ashoka staff select the competition finalists.
    Voting - August 15 to August 28, 2007: Popular online voting to select the three award winners from the field of finalists. The Changemakers Collaborative Competition winners will be announced on August 29, 2007.



The Changemakers Collaborative Competition will include a cash prize of US$5,000 for the top three winners.


Participating in the competition provides the chance to get feedback on your model and to advise potential investors about how best to change funding/investing patterns for the sector and to maximize the strategic impact and effectiveness of their future investments. The competition will generate an Investor Advisory available to investors, foundations, and other funding agencies. Those participants whose contributions most help frame the contents of the advisory will be acknowledged and may be convened to advise investors at a global meeting



Disclaimer—Compliance with Legal Restrictions



Ashoka complies fully with all U.S. laws and regulations, including Office of Foreign Assets Control regulations, export control, and anti-money laundering laws. All grants will be awarded subject to compliance with such laws. Ashoka will not make any grant if it finds that to do so would be unlawful. This may prohibit awards in certain countries and/or to certain individuals or entities. All recipients will comply with these laws to the extent they are applicable to such recipients. No recipient will take any action that would cause Ashoka to violate any laws. Additionally, Ashoka will not make any grant to a company involved in the promotion of tobacco use.




For more information, contact disruptiveinnovations@changemakers.net. Or see our new FAQ

Mosaic of Innovative Solutions™

Disruptive Innovations in Health and Health Care:

Solutions People Want

(What is a Mosaic of Solutions™?)


Disruptive innovation is a concept developed by Harvard Business School Professor Clayton Christensen that has gained widespread traction in the business world, and increasingly in the social sector. According to Christensen, a disruptive innovation is a technology, process, or business model that brings to market a product or service that is much more affordable and much simpler to use than what is currently available. It enables more consumers in the market to afford and/or have the ability to use the product or service. The change caused by such an innovation is so big that it eventually replaces, or disrupts, the established approach to providing that product or service.

Health and health care services historically have been provider-driven and procedure-centered, treating patients as passive participants. Recasting patients as consumers puts them in an active role and challenges the system to meet consumers' interests in managing their health and health care in ways that are more affordable, more accessible, simpler, and more convenient.



 INSIGHTS
 Emerging
 from
 Innovative Solutions:


Main MAIN BARRIERS:


Health Care Not Consumer Friendly

Patients Not Empowered

Complex, Expensive Medicine

Monopolies of Knowledge

 Democratize Access

 

Green House*
(USA)


Revamped nursing homes as structured small group residences to promote independent living for elderly people. Lower overhead costs mean lower user fees.

Aravind Eye Hospital
(India)


Specializes in cataract surgery for the poor, attracting and training eye care specialists around the world. By exploiting its focus on one procedure in a vertically integrated model, its high patient volume reduces per-patient cost and improves patient outcomes.
 

 Simplify through Technologies

 

 


Angio Clubs
(USA)


User groups of physicians meet to discuss patient cases, new technology and how to improve their practice. They focus on minimally invasive angiography not as a procedure promoted by a medical company, but to diagnose and treat abdominal, thoracic and other conditions that were previously costly and eluded easy care.

 

 Center Consumer in Business Model

 

Pedro Chaná*
(Chile)


Unites neurologists, psychiatrists and occupational therapists in 'clubhouses' for people with motor disorders, letting patients make the decisions.

Minute clinics
(USA)


Retail-based clinics where physician assistants provide walk-ins with diagnosis and prescriptions for 16 commonly occurring illnesses in 15 minutes. Detailed protocols and prompts ensure quick, accurate diagnosis.

Working Today
(USA)

Organized group insurance for the self-employed, which costs 30% to 40% less than incumbent insurers. Pooling risk and uniting interests has eliminated the costly barriers to insurance for the self-employed.

 Push Work Down the Chain
 of Command


Rebecca Villalobos*
(Costa Rica)


ASEMBIS uses tiered pricing to provide low-cost glasses through its high-volume, cost-efficient specialty clinics, where doctors use the latest technology. She is adapting her model of participatory vision treatment to other health fields, including hearing and dental care, for large-scale diagnosis and care.

My Medical Control
(USA)


Web-based company that reviews doctor and hospital bills for consumers to check for unnecessary charges and bring transparency and accountability to medical billing.

Dr. Jose Americo Silva Fontes*
(Brazil)


Creates alternatives to expensive medical equipment for neonatal care using bottles, cotton netting and other widely available items that new parents can use at home.

Krzysztof Liszcz*
(Poland)


Monetizes motherhood and confers control by certifying mothers of cerebral palsy children to become paid home-health care workers, reducing state expense.


* Ashoka Fellows


Participate   • Discuss &nbsp • Read the Overall Framework of the Competition



Barriers

Barriers to what consumers want:

  • Health Care Not Consumer Friendly: Consumers want health care that fits their needs. The design of many health businesses, technologies and procedures is inconvenient, embarrassing, and even painful to the patient. The health care system frequently requires patients to alter their behavior to conform to the demands of how care is organized and services are delivered. Consumer centered health services would reorient care to better fit how people live their lives.

  • Patients Not Empowered: Consumers want choices about where, when, and how they get their health care as well as what they receive. They want to be active participants in their care. However, the health care system often dictates the time, place and conditions under which care is provided, leaving the patient powerless. Consumer centered health services would recast the patient as a consumer of health care services, not as a passive receiver.

  • Complex, Expensive Medicine: Consumers want a more affordable health care product with value they can clearly identify. Their definition of health success is based on how quickly their infection ends or how little their chronic disease interrupts their life. Visiting the doctor by itself does not constitute success (getting the job done). Consumer centered health services would be outcome-driven, focusing technology and procedures on efficacy, convenience and speed in improving patient health.

  • Monopolies of Knowledge: Consumers want access to the best care available. But much of care currently is provided by a limited pool of highly trained providers using complex technologies. This puts it out of reach for too many people because of the skill necessary to provide the care and the cost that comes with highly-skilled providers. Consumer centered health services would shift labor and control in ways that everyone would win.


Insights

Insights represent new standards emerging from practical applications that are meant to inspire and guide the innovation process. Note that although the best solutions probably involve more than one insight, in the mosaic below we have chosen to emphasize one specific innovative aspect. If you would like to learn about the multiple innovations behind each solution, please click on each name in the mosaic for a fuller description of each case.

  • Democratize Access: Many innovations in health care tend to put specialty services ever further out of financial reach of the uninsured and indigent. Publicly supported services for those who cannot pay are in chronically short supply and tend to focus on primary care for the masses at the expense of costlier specialty needs of the few. Disruptive innovations, by contrast, take advantage of efficiencies that can make health care services more affordable and available to a broader population.

  • Simplify through Technologies: Many innovations in health care involve technology that introduces additional costs as well as complexity, making health care even less accessible. Disruptive innovations, by contrast, use technology to simplify an existing treatment or diagnostic process.

  • Center Consumer in Business Model: Many innovations in health care organize services in ways that are at the expense of the consumer or ignore the consumer altogether, Disruptive innovations, by contrast, are designed to do the job that consumers want done.

  • Push Work Down the Chain of Command: Many innovations in health care require ever more specialized training and use sophisticated and expensive technology. Disruptive innovations, by contrast, delegate skills and enable the technologies and procedures to be used by non-specialists or even by patients themselves, creating real value throughout the system.



    Short Descriptions of Mosaic Cases


    1.   Revamped nursing homes as structured small group residences to promote independent living for elderly people


      Organization: Green House


      Location: USA


      Website:
      www.greenhouseproject.com


      Mosaic Insight: Democratize Access


      Mosaic Barrier: Patients Not Empowered

      The Green House Project is creating a new way of living for people who need long-term care by replacing traditional institutional facilities with family-size homes of 10 residents or fewer, each with private bedrooms and baths around a common area.

      Developed by geratrician William H.Thomas and driven by the principle of healthy human development, the Green Houses promote independent living for senior residents. Staff members blend the roles of caregiver, homemaker and friend. Called "shahbaz" ("powerful falcon" in Farsi), they are certified nurse's aides who train an additional 200 hours in first aid, cooking, listening, team building and other skills. In a reversal of typical nursing home hierarchy, shahbaz manage the household, supported by nurses and therapists. Costs are kept low, savings coming from streamlining jobs, shifting resources and keeping overheads down. Monthly fees are on par with the national average monthly fee in a nursing home and Medicaid covers the cost for 90 percent of the residents.

      Go back to the mosaic




    2.   Cataract surgery for the poor: high patient volume reduces per-patient cost and improves patient outcomes


      Organization: Aravind Eye Hospital


      Location: India


      Website:
      www.aravind.org


      Mosaic Insight: Democratize Access


      Mosaic Barrier: Complex, Expensive Medicine

      Aravind Eye Hospital, a WHO Collaborating Centre for Prevention of Blindness, provides a range of eye care services from primary to tertiary eye care through its network of five eye hospitals with a combined bed capacity of 3,500.

      Aravind is not merely a chain of hospitals; its supplies and resources reach the unreached through structured community outreach programs, a center for manufacturing eye care supplies/consumables, development of well trained human resources, active promotion of evidence based eye care through a dedicated research institute, an international eye bank, and a postgraduate institute of ophthalmology.

      Aravind's mission to eliminate needless blindness maintains its commitment in providing high quality, compassionate eye care to all those in need, using the multi-tiered pricing approach. One of the key factors for its effectiveness is in adopting appropriate systems and processes that provide affordable eye care services either at subsidized or no cost.

      From its inception in 1976, Aravind has screened 21.7 million outpatients and performed around 2.8 million sight restoring surgeries. Its high volume of surgery makes it the largest eye care provider in the world. The Aravind model is being replicated globally through Lions Aravind Institute of Community Ophthalmology (LAICO), Asia's first eye care training and capacity building institute.

      Go back to the mosaic




    3.   User groups of physicians focus on minimally invasive angiography


      Organization: Angio Clubs


      Location: USA


      Mosaic Insight:
      Simplify through Technologies


      Mosaic Barrier: Complex, Expensive Medicine

      The establishment of the angio clubs fulfilled in part the need for members to share information and to learn from each other. They were important as a means for members to educate and alert each other to the incidence and nature of complications.

      Frank discussions at the angio clubs played a critical role in the early development and acceptance of angiography as a safe diagnostic method. Soon it became obvious that geographic expansion of the city-based angio clubs would bring more angiographers together to share the latest advances in the new field. This led to the organization of regional meetings.

      Go back to the mosaic




    4.   Unites caregivers in "clubhouses" for people with motor disorders, letting patients make the decisions


      Project Leader: Pedro Chaná


      Organization: Center for the Study of Motor Disorders (CETRAM)


      Location: Chile


      Mosaic Insight:
      Center Consumer in Business Model


      Mosaic Barrier: Patients Not Empowered

      Pedro Chaná, a medical doctor and an Ashoka Fellow, has evolved a health delivery model that empowers patients with chronic motor disorders by putting them in a one-on-one, inclusionary partnership with doctors that topples the top-down doctor-patient relationship. Together, through a network of "clubhouses," they work out treatment and rehabilitation, thereby democratizing medical professionals' approach to long-term care that forces doctors to become highly sensitive and caring of the individual needs of patients. In a total overhauling of the traditional system, the doctor is no longer the singular expert and patients are no longer subservient recipients of treatment.

      The patients and their families are encouraged to educate themselves about the illness and treatment options and to make informed, consensual choices along with their doctor. Moreover, now clubhouse members are able to demand and receive medical attention from a whole range of specialists like neurologists, psychiatrists and occupational therapists-something that would have been unthinkable earlier.

      Through Chaná's Center for the Study of Motor Disorders (CETRAM), patients associations are also collectively buying expensive drugs at cost price and procuring unavailable drugs and selling them through CETRAM clubhouses at 30 percent less than the market rate. All patients have equal access to quality treatment and payment is determined by the financial situation of the patient.

      Go back to the mosaic




    5.   Retail-based clinics where physician assistants provide walk-ins


      Organization: Minute Clinics


      Location: USA


      Website:
      www.minuteclinic.com


      Mosaic Insight: Center Consumer in Business Model


      Mosaic Barrier: Complex, Expensive Medicine

      Located in mini-malls and discount stores and sporting catchy slogans such as "You're Sick, We're Quick," a new wave of retail health clinics is transforming the American health care landscape by offering quick, convenient diagnosis and prescriptions for a range of common illnesses.

      Well-laid down protocols ensure swift, accurate care thereby reducing inappropriate use of hospital emergency facilties for basic medical services. For the un- and under-insured, the clinics offer an alternative route to access primary care services. The retail clinic model relies on low prices, quick throughput of patients, minimal staff, and propriety software systems that can reliably manage selective medical diagnoses and information of a short list of simple procedures. Most are staffed with non-physician practitioners (typically physician's assistants or nurse practitioners) who provide basic medical care, including writing prescriptions, for a limited number of conditions.

      Visits take approximately 15 minutes. Patients with significant or unusual medical concerns are referred to outside physicians.

      Go back to the mosaic




    6.   Organized group insurance for the self-employed that costs 30% to 40% less


      Organization: Working Today


      Location: USA


      Website:
      www.workingtoday.org


      Mosaic Insight: Center Consumer in Business Model


      Mosaic Barrier: Monopolies of Knowledge

      In the prevalent employer-centered benefits model of workplace USA, Working Today is creating safety nets for the rapidly expanding army of independent workers through a portable benefits delivery system with benefits linked to the individual rather than the employer.

      Working Today's members work in industries ranging from media and technology to domestic childcare-and due to their non-traditional employment arrangements, they do not have access to employer-based benefits, such as health insurance. It enables independent workers who previously remained unisured or severely underinsured to access group-rate health insurance plans in New York State priced at less than one-third of the average price in the individual market. Thus, by pooling risk and uniting interests, it has eliminated the costly barriers to insurance for the self-employed.

      Go back to the mosaic




    7.   Tiered pricing that provides low-cost glasses through high-volume, cost-efficient specialty clinics


      Project Leader: Rebeca Villalobos


      Organization: Asociación de Servicios Médicos para el Bien Social (ASEMBIS)


      Location: Costa Rica


      Website:
      www.asembiscr.com


      Mosaic Insight: Push Work Down the Chain of Command


      Mosaic Barrier: Health Care Not Consumer Friendly

      Rebeca Villalobos has developed a participatory system of eyecare that enables Costa Ricans of all classes to access affordable medical services ranging from basic vision tests to sophisticated surgical procedures. By reconceptualizing the field of eyecare, this Ashoka Fellow is ensuring the affordability of vision care for even the poorest.

      Her program incorporates large-scale diagnosis, low-cost glasses, high-volume, and cost-efficient specialty clinics to detect and correct vision and health problems on a huge scale. Thus far, over 1,900,000 patients have benefited from the intervention.

      Villalobos plans on adapting her model of participatory vision treatment to other health fields, including hearing and dental care, where citizen-based initiatives and community partnerships could substantially reduce the incidence of preventable illness in Costa Rica and around Latin America. ASEMBIS started in 1991 with a total capital of $700, and it has taken them four years to attain self sustainability.

      Go back to the mosaic




    8.   Web-based company reviews doctor and hospital bills for consumers


      Organization: My Medical Control


      Location: USA


      Website:
      www.mymedicalcontrol.com


      Mosaic Insight: Push Work Down the Chain of Command


      Mosaic Barrier: Patients Not Empowered

      Web-based company My Medical Control (MMC) is ensuring that consumers no longer remain helpless victims of the arbitrary opacity in medical care pricing by reviewing doctor and hospital bills for clients to ascertain they are being charged a fair price.

      It is estimated that overall out-of-pocket medical expenses for consumers will rise more than five percent every year. Already, over 12 percent of working-age adults have out-of-pocket medical costs greater than five percent of their annual household income. MMC reviews that part of the consumer's bills are not covered by their insurance plans. It compares the medical claim or bill against a sophisticated medical claim reimbursement database (their "fair-pricing" database) to ensure that the consumer is being "charged" what the provider generally "accepts" for the same or similar services. If there is a discrepancy between the "charged" amount and the generally "accepted" amount, the Company intervenes with the medical provider on behalf of the consumer, and attempts to settle the bill for the more "reasonable" amount. If successful in settling the consumers' claim for less, MMC charges a professional service fee that is a small percentage of the saved amount. If it cannot save the consumer money or judge the claim to be "fair and reasonable", there is no charge. The turn-around time for the service (from submission to result) is a quick 15 minutes.

      Go back to the mosaic




    9.   Creates alternatives to expensive medical equipment for neonatal care


      Project Leader: Dr. Jose Americo Silva Fontes


      Location: Brazil


      Mosaic Insight:
      Push Work Down the Chain of Command


      Mosaic Barrier: Complex, Expensive Medicine

      With "humanizing, simplifying, and preventative" as his credo, pediatrician Jose Americo Silva Fontes, is providing affordable, high-quality neo-natal care in Brazil's resource-strapped public hospitals.

      Fontes, an Ashoka Fellow, replaces costly hi-tech equipment with inexpensive, everyday household and hospital items modified to turn them into lifesaving devices. Tupperware containers and glass water bottles morph into oxygen hoods for babies; phototherapy units are constructed from track lighting, cotton netting, and dimmer switches; a pacifier with a eardropper inside allows a baby with clogged nasal passage to draw in air. At the hospitals, he works with nurses and mothers to train them to apply his principles to the care of the children. Hospitals, clinics, and even families are thus able to have the benefits normally thought possible only from equipment (usually imported) that costs many times more.

      Fontes has now created a foundation to continue developing and distributing new low cost equipment across Brazil and internationally.

      Go back to the mosaic




    10.   Monetizes motherhood, certifying mothers to become paid home-health care workers


      Project Leader: Krzysztof Liszcz


      Location: Poland


      Mosaic Insight:
      Push Work Down the Chain of Command


      Mosaic Barrier: Monopolies of Knowledge

      Ashoka Fellow Krzysztof Liszcz, a doctor of medicine, has developed a home-based program of care for children with cerebral palsy wherein mothers are trained to function as their own children's caregivers. His program reduces state expenditures in half while certifying the mothers so that they can earn money with their new skills. The para-professional therapist mothers not only earn salaries while tending to their children, but are also provided with insurance and a pension after twenty years.

      Liszcz's training methods are geared to accelerate the development of these children's cognitive and motor skills, sorely missing in Poland's overburdened and bureaucratic institutions that are unable to help the children realize their full potential. The program also addresses the challenges of economic hardship that inevitably arise in a scenario where one parent of such children (usually the mother) is pressed to opt out of the job market so as to do unremunerated care-giving work at home. Or, conversely, financial necessity forces parents to institutionalize their children in the full knowledge that the three 40-minute physical therapy sessions per week per child that the state provides is inadequate for the child's development.

      At the core of his program are regional Self-Support Circles that bring together families, professionals and volunteers who collaborate to provide each group of families with counseling, peer support, child care and training. This system is designed to provide options and tools to parents that make them independent of the traditional institutional medical care system.

      Go back to the mosaic