Engendering governance- Making Violence Against Women a Concern for Village level Elected bodies (gram panchayats)
There are several laws in India to combat Violence Against Women (VAW) but VAW is on the rise. The reason is that legislation can never bring about social change. For this it is important that the institutions representing the society and those that provide contemporary leadership namely, the locally elected bodies become active in combating VAW.
The passage of the Constitution (73rd Amendment) Act, 1992 marked a new era in the federal democratic set up of India. It provided constitutional status to the Panchayati Raj ( local governance institutions) Institutions at the three levels of District, Block and village thus encompassing the entire length and breadth of the country. Article 243 G in Part IX of the Constitution provides for the empowerment of Panchayati Raj Institutions to function as institutions of self government. The village panchayat is the vital link in this chain responsible for planning and implementing economic development and social justice in their respective areas.
The 11th schedule of the Constitution, lists out 29 matters for which Panchayats are empowered to function as units of self government. Women and child development and violence against women and children is one of the 29 areas for which a panchayat is responsible. But just as society neglects women, in the same manner village panchayats too have reneged from their role in preventing VAW. The village panchayats regard domestic violence against women as customary and an issue that is a private matter of the family. It is important that the panchayats fulfill their constitutional obligation and begin to recognize violence as an obstruction to not just women’s development but overall social development and a concern for them to address.
The 73rd amendment provided for 33% reservation for women at all levels of the panchayati Raj system. The Act has placed women into a strategic position of influencing development and place on board the governance concerns of women. However the Panchayat experience for most elected women panchayat representatives (EWRs) is an extension of the patriarchal social system where they are not allowed to play an active role, are discriminated against and face violence.
The Panchayati Raj will achieve its goals of social justice and equity for women and the millennium development goal of gender equality and empowerment stand a better chance of achievement by year 2015 if panchayats function as true units of self government and address the issues of discrimination and VAW in their respective areas .
The project is a pilot initiative and we aim to work over a period of three years in three districts of Gujarat with 100 gram panchayats towards activating and empowering them in addressing the social justice and violence related concerns of women. This scale we feel will provide the critical mass of know-how and experience, so necessary to create acceptance and mainstream the issue of VAW in Panchayati Raj Institutions .
The project is a pilot initiative and we aim to work over a period of three years in three diverse districts of Gujarat with 75 gram panchayats towards activating and empowering them in addressing the social justice and violence related concerns of women. This scale we feel will provide the critical mass of know-how and experience and so necessary to create acceptance and mainstream the issue of VAW in Panchayati Raj Institutions .
The program is innovative in that it aims to work extensively with village level panchayats to own responsibility for preventing and reducing the incidence of VAW.
It identifies the panchayat leadership as a major catalytic force in the village and capable of influencing community opinion against VAW.
It sets up village level vigilance committees of men and women, which are community led social defense systems which makes the community accountable and continuously involved in discussing the right and wrong and just-unjust and push the boundaries of the socio-cultural framework that justifies violence.
The project will focus on activating gram panchayats to play their role through publicly announcing their intent to not tolerate VAW and set up measures to monitor and prevent it at the level of the vaillage . It will work towards making panchayats aware and enforcing the statutory role of the panchayat in supporting women get protection and support against VAW.
It holds promise of engendering governance by empowering and organizing women to engage with these bodies on activating their role in monitoring and preventing VAW.
The learning and experience of the projet will be shared through state level, regional and national consultations . The consultations will be used for advocacy to mainstream violence against women as a governance concern and formalise in practise the role of panchayts in preventing VAW.
About You
Section 1: About You
First Name
poonam
Last Name
kathuria
Website
Organization
Society for Women's Action and training inititative
Country
India, GJ
Section 2: About Your Organization
Is this initiative/innovation linked to any established organization?
Yes
Organization Name
Society for Women's Action and training inititative
Organization Website
Organization Phone
91 79 26302676
Organization Address
b-2, sunshine apartments, Dr.S.R Marg, Ahmedabad 380 015, Gujarat, India
Organization Country
India
Is your organization a
CSO/NGO
How long has this organization been operating?
More than 5 years
Your idea
Name Your Project
Engendering governance- Making Violence Against Women a Concern for Village level Elected bodies (gram panchayats)
What stage is your project in?
Idea phase
When was the project initiated? or When are you planning to begin?
The implementation is planned from May 2010.
Describe your idea and explain why it is innovative
There are several laws in India to combat Violence Against Women (VAW) but VAW is on the rise. The reason is that legislation can never bring about social change. For this it is important that the institutions representing the society and those that provide contemporary leadership namely, the locally elected bodies become active in combating VAW.
The passage of the Constitution (73rd Amendment) Act, 1992 marked a new era in the federal democratic set up of India. It provided constitutional status to the Panchayati Raj ( local governance institutions) Institutions at the three levels of District, Block and village thus encompassing the entire length and breadth of the country. Article 243 G in Part IX of the Constitution provides for the empowerment of Panchayati Raj Institutions to function as institutions of self government. The village panchayat is the vital link in this chain responsible for planning and implementing economic development and social justice in their respective areas.
The 11th schedule of the Constitution, lists out 29 matters for which Panchayats are empowered to function as units of self government. Women and child development and violence against women and children is one of the 29 areas for which a panchayat is responsible. But just as society neglects women, in the same manner village panchayats too have reneged from their role in preventing VAW. The village panchayats regard domestic violence against women as customary and an issue that is a private matter of the family. It is important that the panchayats fulfill their constitutional obligation and begin to recognize violence as an obstruction to not just women’s development but overall social development and a concern for them to address.
The 73rd amendment provided for 33% reservation for women at all levels of the panchayati Raj system. The Act has placed women into a strategic position of influencing development and place on board the governance concerns of women. However the Panchayat experience for most elected women panchayat representatives (EWRs) is an extension of the patriarchal social system where they are not allowed to play an active role, are discriminated against and face violence.
The Panchayati Raj will achieve its goals of social justice and equity for women and the millennium development goal of gender equality and empowerment stand a better chance of achievement by year 2015 if panchayats function as true units of self government and address the issues of discrimination and VAW in their respective areas .
The project is a pilot initiative and we aim to work over a period of three years in three districts of Gujarat with 100 gram panchayats towards activating and empowering them in addressing the social justice and violence related concerns of women. This scale we feel will provide the critical mass of know-how and experience, so necessary to create acceptance and mainstream the issue of VAW in Panchayati Raj Institutions .
The project is a pilot initiative and we aim to work over a period of three years in three diverse districts of Gujarat with 75 gram panchayats towards activating and empowering them in addressing the social justice and violence related concerns of women. This scale we feel will provide the critical mass of know-how and experience and so necessary to create acceptance and mainstream the issue of VAW in Panchayati Raj Institutions .
The program is innovative in that it aims to work extensively with village level panchayats to own responsibility for preventing and reducing the incidence of VAW.
It identifies the panchayat leadership as a major catalytic force in the village and capable of influencing community opinion against VAW.
It sets up village level vigilance committees of men and women, which are community led social defense systems which makes the community accountable and continuously involved in discussing the right and wrong and just-unjust and push the boundaries of the socio-cultural framework that justifies violence.
The project will focus on activating gram panchayats to play their role through publicly announcing their intent to not tolerate VAW and set up measures to monitor and prevent it at the level of the vaillage . It will work towards making panchayats aware and enforcing the statutory role of the panchayat in supporting women get protection and support against VAW.
It holds promise of engendering governance by empowering and organizing women to engage with these bodies on activating their role in monitoring and preventing VAW.
The learning and experience of the projet will be shared through state level, regional and national consultations . The consultations will be used for advocacy to mainstream violence against women as a governance concern and formalise in practise the role of panchayts in preventing VAW.
What kind of beneficiaries is your initiative addressed to?
Women, Girls, Society in general.
Describe the profile of the beneficiaries of this project
The project reaches out to a diverse set of beneficiaries at various levels.
• Its primary beneficiaries are the Women and girls in general
• Women survivors of Violence.
• Womens grassroots level federations
• Local governance bodies –elected leaders and administration
The other beneficiaries of the project would be:
• Men and Boys
• Legal System: Lawyers, judges
• Media
• Other NGOs and
• Society / general community
The project plans to reach out to about seven lakh population directly.
What is your initiative’s implementation strategy?
The Gujarat state Panchayat Act lists 125 cr. Pc a civil law under which a panchayat has the responsibility of submitting a investigation report if the court directs them. By the same logic PWDVA , 2005 a civil law comes under similar provisions. In the current scenario 125 Cr. Pc ( provides for maintenace to wives,mothers, minor children and any other dependents) is an act most used by women and the PWDVA is an act that looks at violence free life as a womans right and accords a women immediate protection against all forms of domestic violence.
The sexual harassment bill 2005, which is awaiting clearance by the parliament specifically holds gram panchayats responsible for enforcement of preventive measures and rederessal systems. The panchayats would be made aware and accountable for their role under these acts.
The project will focus on activating gram Panchayats to play their role through publicly announcing their intent to not tolerate VAW and set up measures to monitor and prevent it at the level of the vaillage . It will work towards making Panchayats aware and enforcing the statutory role of the Panchayat in supporting women get protection and support against VAW.
The gram panchayats are highly patriarchal bodies, and to enable them to address the issue in a gender just approach it is important that they set up systems with women’s involvement and leadership at the level of the panchayat and the village and the block so that VAW is monitored and redressed in a gender just manner. It is also important that women are empowered to engage with these elected bodies and demand that they play a role in combating VAW
To achieve this project will actively and widely replicate in conjunction with working with village panchayats two best practices that we have already been implementing with proven impact.
a) Set up village level vigilance committees comprising of women and men of the village, panchayat members and active members of women’s Self help groups to aid gram panchayats to play their role; and
b) Build women’s leadership and capacities towards setting up alternate redress mechanism –in the form of Women’s Nyaya Samitis -the women justice committees, that are area level community based , women led forums that are trained to function in a socio-legal and gender just framework to help women seek redressal to combat VAW.
The basis of linking Women’s Nyaya Samitis to activating Gram Panchayats and men is in the fact that we recognizes that women are not single gendered and men’s subjectivity is central to gender domination. However the leadership and perspective to combat VAW has to be provided by women as it is only they who can question widen through dialogue the boundaries of Socio-cultural frames which justify male violence within the house hold as their right.
In your opinion, what are the main barriers or obstacles in connection with this theme?
Panchayats ( electected bodies at the level of the village in-charge of self- rule and governance) like society have neglected the issue of VAW and reneged from their constitutional responsibility of equity and social justice for women . Patriarchal mindsets, acceptance of VAW and lack of awareness are mainly responsible for this.
we find that the governments are showcasing the laws as ( their) claim to women’s equality, without putting in place the implementation and monitoring mechanisms necessary for the law to become an operational reality for women.
Governments- state and national lack the political will and the motivation to allocate resources to ensure setting up of adequate infrastructure and mechanisms to ensure implementation of the laws.
The laws are often put in place in a top down manner without creating the enabling environment at society level by way of awareness and change in attitudes. Hence face cultural barriers to achievement of women’s Rights.
A corrupt, over burdened and sluggish law enforcement mechanism is a deterrent to women seeking enforcement of Rights this combined with women’s lack of resources , information has led to a situation where the intent of laws and policies for women’s equality is yet to make a substantive impact .
What type of partnerships you have or intend to generate strategic alliances with for the development of this initiative? Choose all that apply
State departments or areas, Non-Government organizations, Universities, Other.
Describe with whom you have generated these alliances and how
1. Increase the outreach of our work and place the issue of VAW on the agenda of grassroots level Womens federations : For the purpose of the initiatve SWATI has forged alliance with grassroots womens federation( colectives of self help groups) in suppporting them to take up this issue in their region as well as setting up support mechnaisms at the level of the federation in supporting – ( set up women justice committees) survivors of VAW through provision of counseling, legal aid and other support. Formal Memorandums of Understanding are being drawn up with the federations and their parent body ( if any)
2. Centre For Social Justice: Is the capacity building and training support agency and will be in charge of trainings for the vigilanece committees and Nyaya samiti members. CSJ has indepth expertise and rights law and Violence against Women.
3. Monitoring and Evaluation: Women's Health Training, Research and Advocacy Cell (WOHTRAC) of Women's Studies Research Centre at The Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda is the agency in-charge of monitoring and evaluation and documentation. The Cell consists of senior faculty members from social sciences including social work and has in-depth expertise in conducting evaluations and research.
4. The Panchayat Ministry: This is one key minisry at both state and national level that we would be liasing with towards forming an alliance.
What are the main results generated and/or expected to generate by means of this initiative?
• Violence against Women gains mainstream acceptance as a concern to be addressed by grassroots governance bodies of elected representatives.
• The Panchayat ministry will look at VAW as an important area for panchayats and make relevant recommendations to the state governments
• Violence against women will be introduced as a topic in panchayat training curricula.
• Women’s capacities and leadership in engaging with men to combat VAW emerge.
• Women seek redressal against VAW and community opinion against VAW emerges
• Community becomes aware of impact of VAW on women and society.
• Gram panchayats would become aware of laws and procedures that support VAW
What is the main impact that your initiative might generate?
• Governance will be engendered towards a gender just framework .
• The Panchayat ministry will look at VAW as an important area for panchayats and make relevant recommendations to the state governments
• Violence against women will be introduced as a topic in panchayat training curricula.
• Protocols would be developed on the role of gram panchayat in VAW
• Women’s Nyaya samitis would gain legitimacy in the justice delivery system in redressal of VAW
• PWDVA an important act based on CEDAW would be better implemented
• Panchayats would have publicly proclaimed their commitment to end VAW by putting up posters, slogans, and exhibits asking women to act against VAW.
This Entry is about (Issues)
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Glimpses_of_SWATIs__Work_to_combat__VAW_Page_1.jpg | 95.25 KB |
| Glimpses_of_SWATIs__Work_to_combat__VAW_Page_2.jpg | 206.36 KB |
| Glimpses_of_SWATIs__Work_to_combat__VAW_Page_3.jpg | 129.49 KB |
| 114 weeks agopoonam kathuria updated this Competition Entry. | |
| 114 weeks agopoonam kathuria updated this Competition Entry. | |
| 114 weeks agopoonam kathuria updated this Competition Entry. | |
| 115 weeks agopoonam kathuria submitted this idea. |

